Information for Selection Committee Members
Selection committee members should familiarise themselves with their responsibilities before reviewing applications.
- Conflict of interest guidelines and declarations (see side bar for policy)
- Responsibilities of the Chair (see Interview Planning Checklist on side bar)
- Managing Unconscious Bias (recommend completing the PULSE module ‘Selection Committee Chair Training’.
Skills Testing & Work Samples
Applicants should be informed in advance if a skills test or work sample assessment will be used as part of the selection process, including when it will occur. These assessments may be used either after interviews or, in some cases, as part of the shortlisting process prior to interview. Hiring managers should include this information in the job advertisement to ensure applicants are aware of the assessment requirements and can prepare accordingly.
- Work sample assessments are designed to evaluate a candidate’s ability to perform tasks typically associated with the role. Examples may include:
- Writing exercises – preparing memos, letters or file notes; researching and analysing information; or providing written advice in response to a hypothetical scenario.
- Planning exercises – developing a project plan or schedule, determining a budget, or allocating resources based on a provided case study.
- Computer-based exercises – creating spreadsheets, tables, letters, presentations, or diagrams.
- Analysis exercises – reviewing quantitative and qualitative information, drawing conclusions, and making recommendations.
Where a skills test or work sample is used, all candidates being assessed at that stage of the process should be provided with the same instructions, information and assessment conditions to ensure a fair and consistent selection process.
Shortlisting Applications
A consistent approach to assessing and ranking candidates should be agreed before interviews commence.
Panel members assess applications against the selection criteria in the position description, noting strengths, concerns, and initial ratings. The Chair can then arrange a panel meeting to determine shortlisted candidates for interview, applicants who will not progress to interview, and any candidates requiring further discussion before a final decision is reached.
Clear records should be kept by the Selection Committee as to the reason why the shortlisted candidates were selected ahead of other candidates.
Applicants who are not shortlisted for interview will be notified of the outcome via a generic email issued by the Recruitment Team. Feedback is not normally provided to applicants who are unsuccessful at the initial shortlisting stage, however, the Chair may provide feedback if an applicant requests it after receiving the email notification.
For those who are shortlisted for interview, please refer to the ‘Interviews’ section below.
Interviews
See an interview planning checklist on the side bar which we recommend using as a guide before, during and after interviews take place.
The Chair of the Selection Committee is responsible for confirming panel availability and agreeing on a suitable interview date and times.
Once an interview date, time, and location have been confirmed:
- The Recruitment Services team can assist with interview scheduling where there are more than five shortlisted candidates.
- For five or fewer shortlisted candidates, interview arrangements should be coordinated by the Chair.
An interview invitation template is available here to assist with arranging interviews.
What if a candidates requests interview adjustments?
If a candidate requests adjustments to support their participation in the interview process, these should be accommodated to ensure an inclusive and barrier-free experience. The Recruitment Team can assist in arranging appropriate adjustments.
Following the interviews:
- The Selection Committee should discuss the relative merits of all candidates against the selection criteria.
- Recommendations should be based on all elements of the selection process, including the written application, interview performance, referee reports, and any relevant assessments or testing.
- The Chair is responsible for providing feedback to interviewed candidates who are unsuccessful, supporting a positive candidate experience and promoting transparency in the recruitment process.
Referee Reports
We encourage conducting verbal referee reports rather than written reports to referees. Verbal reports are preferred as they provide detailed and meaningful feedback, more open discussions and allow hiring managers to ask questions and gather additional information.
If you do choose a written referee report, please ensure it is objective, evidence-based, and provides sufficient detail to support a fair and equitable assessment of the candidate's suitability for the role.
To assist with the shortlisting process, please find a shortlisting tool here.
A link to the referee report template can be found here.
Selection Report
Once the preferred candidate has been identified, the Chair is responsible for completing the Selection Report. The report provides a record of the selection process and the rationale for the Committee's recommendation.
A selection committee report template is available here.
The Selection Report should accurately reflect the Committee's decision-making process and demonstrate that candidates have been assessed fairly, consistently and on merit. It needs to include:
- Non – shortlisted candidates section, including the reasons candidates did not progress to interview.
- Short listed candidates and interview outcomes section, summarising the Committee's assessment of candidates against the selection criteria.
- The recommended candidate details completed under the ‘Details of Person to Receive Offer’ section of the report. (updated once new template approved)
- Any conflict-of-interest declarations relevant to the recruitment process.
- If a skills test or work sample assessment is used, the results and outcomes must be documented in the Selection Report as part of the overall assessment of each candidate. This should include a summary of the task, the assessment criteria applied, and how the candidate performed against those criteria.
- Any conditions associated with the recommendation, where applicable, for example appointments above the base step in the salary range or those where a loading will be provided.
- Endorsement by the Committee under the ‘Recommendation’ section of the report.
- Approval by the relevant Delegate of the area under ‘Approval of Selection Report’ section of the report
Reference documents
- Interview Planning Checklist (PDF, 557.69 KB)
- Selection Committee Member Guide (PDF, 126.65 KB)
- Interview Invitation Template (DOCX, 5 MB)
Use contact details to request an alternative file format.